| Rank | Title | Section | Hits
|
|---|
| 1 | Me And My Teenage Girlfriend Babysitters  | Contributed Stories | 1847
|
| 2 | The Brady Boys In Bunches of Diapers | Contributed Stories | 1358
|
| 3 | Oops  | Contributed Stories | 1306
|
| 4 | Diapers and Duel Monsters | Contributed Stories | 1281
|
| 5 | Larry's Summer | Contributed Stories | 1250
|
| 6 | Brian's Dilemma | Contributed Stories | 1210
|
| 7 | Tommy | Contributed Stories | 662
|
| 8 | Forever in Diapers | Deeker's Stories | 345
|
| 9 | Aunt Mandy | Contributed Stories | 145
|
| 10 | The Ad | Contributed Stories | 122
|
